China News  
The looting of the Summer Palace: a colonial humiliation in China

French judge authorises sale of Chinese bronzes
A French judge authorised Monday the sale of two Chinese bronzes at an auction of Yves Saint Laurent artworks, rejecting a plea for them to be returned to China. The 18th century Qing dynasty bronzes -- part of a collection looted 150 years ago by British and French troops from the imperial Summer Palace -- are to go under the hammer on Wednesday. Saint Laurent's partner Pierre Berge, who decided to sell their joint art collection following the designer's death last year, said the judge took the right decision and reiterated an offer to trade the relics against rights. "I'm absolutely ready to give the two heads to China," he said. "The only thing I ask is for China to give human rights, liberty to Tibet and to welcome the Dalai Lama." A French-based Chinese art association, Apace, had asked the judge to serve an injunction preventing the sale, arguing the bronzes remain stolen property, but the court decided it had no jurisdiction to rule in the case. The association has wanted the court to force the French state to intervene and negotiate the return of the items with Beijing authorities. The prosecutor described it as a "cavalier" plea and "abuse of procedure" by "an association that only represents itself" and called on the court to fine Apace "because a minimum of respect for justice is called for." A lawyer for the Association to Protect Chinese Art in Europe group told the court its aim was to "alert public opinion on the fate of numerous Chinese works stolen in the past and sold through trafficking." Christie's, which is organising the three-day 300 million euro (392 million dollar) auction of the Saint Laurent/Berge collection, has consistently argued there are no legal grounds to bar the sale of the two rare pieces. The three-day sale began Monday.
by Staff Writers
Beijing (AFP) Feb 23, 2009
The looting of the Summer Palace in Beijing is one of the most infamous episodes of colonial abuse in China -- a humiliation that remains vivid nearly 150 years on.

The auctioning in Paris of two imperial bronze relics that were part of the booty seized by the British in 1860 has opened this wound and become a rallying cry for nationalists.

"The looting of the Summer Palace (Yuanmingyuan) by the French and the English, and the fire started by the British, remains an unforgivable crime in Chinese memory," Bernard Brizay, author of a book on the subject, told AFP.

"For the French, it would be the same as if the Prussians in 1870 had razed Versailles down to the ground, looted the Louvre (museum) and set fire to the national library, as the Yuanmingyuan was all of those at once," he said.

In October 1860, towards the end of the Second Opium War -- which pitted the British and the French against China for four years from 1856 -- foreign troops reached Beijing.

Soldiers first looted what the Chinese now call the Old Summer Palace, and then came back to set fire to the place in retaliation for the death and torture of French and British hostages.

The Western-style palace had been built northwest of the Chinese capital at the heyday of the Qing dynasty, and emperors had made it a habit to go there to escape the Forbidden City and stifling heat during the summer.

The looting and burning of the palace was a shock not only for the Chinese but also for foreigners such as the French writer Victor Hugo, who denounced the destruction of this "splendid and sensational museum of the East".

"In the eyes of history, one of the two outlaws will be called France, the other will be called England," he wrote.

"I hope there will come a day when France, liberated and cleaned up, will send back this booty to a plundered China."

Today, Chinese lawyers are playing the nationalist card as they drum up local support for a legal campaign in France to stop the relics being sold at the Christie's auction.

"The looting of the Summer Palace is a wound that has never really healed. Selling these objects that were stolen from us is like pouring salt on the wound," said Beijing attorney Liu Yang, who is leading the group's efforts.

Brizay also said government propaganda was keeping alive the "painful memory".

Indeed, the Chinese government has spoken out forcefully on the issue.

"Auctioning cultural objects looted in war time not only offends the Chinese people and undermines their cultural rights, but also violates relevant international conventions," Chinese foreign ministry spokeswoman Jiang Yu said.

Share This Article With Planet Earth
del.icio.usdel.icio.us DiggDigg RedditReddit
YahooMyWebYahooMyWeb GoogleGoogle FacebookFacebook



Related Links
China News from SinoDaily.com



Memory Foam Mattress Review
Newsletters :: SpaceDaily :: SpaceWar :: TerraDaily :: Energy Daily
XML Feeds :: Space News :: Earth News :: War News :: Solar Energy News


Crisis brings threat of crime wave to China
Shenzhen, China (AFP) Feb 22, 2009
Yang Zhili did not think the economic crisis would affect his quiet daily routine as a taxi driver in the southern Chinese city of Shenzhen until two passengers tried to rob him at knife-point.







  • France in NATO: What would de Gaulle say?
  • Clinton wraps Asia trip by asking China to buy US debt
  • Clinton hopes to build on solid Sino-US foundation
  • Clinton sees new role for Indonesia in US 'smart power'

  • Obama heads to Canada to talk trade, turn page on Bush
  • US-China tensions rise amid financial chaos: experts
  • China trade with Taiwan, Hong Kong plunged in Jan: report
  • Chinese trade city a magnet for Arabs, Africans

  • One killed in Romanian military lab explosion
  • China quake victims clash with police: rights group
  • Rudd says Australia will rise from 'ashes of despair'
  • Australian wildfire death toll rises to 208: police

  • China Plans To Launch Third Ocean Survey Satellite In 2010
  • Satellite Collision Not To Delay China's Space Program
  • China plans own satellite navigation system by 2015: state media
  • Fengyun-3A Weather Satellite Begins Weather Monitoring

  • BP to pay 179 million dollars to settle Texas pollution case
  • Analysis: Khodorkovsky in court again
  • Blast damages NATO oil tanker in Pakistan: official
  • Analysis: Iran wants Turkmen gas

  • Climate Change May Alter Malaria Patterns
  • Hong Kong bird tests positive for H5N1
  • China bird flu not pandemic, but be prepared: UN
  • AIDS now China's deadliest infectious disease: govt

  • Iraq invites France back to build nuclear plant
  • US nuclear plants must prepare for plane attacks
  • Latvia, Estonia push for Baltic nuclear plant
  • French firm studying Kuwait's nuclear programme: emir

  • 74 dead in China mine blast: state media
  • US clings to coal energy but wants it clean
  • China's deadly coal mines kill fewer people in 2008: reports
  • Chinese mining company covered up flood deaths: state media

  • The content herein, unless otherwise known to be public domain, are Copyright 1995-2007 - SpaceDaily.AFP and UPI Wire Stories are copyright Agence France-Presse and United Press International. ESA Portal Reports are copyright European Space Agency. All NASA sourced material is public domain. Additional copyrights may apply in whole or part to other bona fide parties. Advertising does not imply endorsement,agreement or approval of any opinions, statements or information provided by SpaceDaily on any Web page published or hosted by SpaceDaily. Privacy Statement